Our History

Allen & Stults Co., Inc. is a Trusted Choice independent insurance agency. Established in Hightstown in 1881 by John Allen & Charles Stults, the agency is currently operated by the fourth generation of the Stults family. For more than 130 years we have served the Families, Businesses and Non-Profit Organizations of New Jersey and beyond. We have grown along with the community and continue to be a company dedicated to providing personalized service to our clients.

Although we are still at our original small town location at 100-106 North Main Street, Allen & Stults Co., Inc. has always been recognized as a leading insurance agency in New Jersey.

We are not only committed to our clients, but remain a strong presence within the insurance industry. Throughout the years, our agency owners have lead both State and National independent insurance organizations providing input and support regarding coverage, ethics and legislative reform.

Allen & Stults Co., Inc. is proud of its history and knows what is important to our clients - a professional, caring staff and a strong, reliable insurance company. We are fully committed to staff continuing education and are constantly upgrading our technology to meet your needs. At the same time, we do not lose sight of our reputation as a family owned, personal service oriented organization. You can always reach us and talk to real people who are familiar with you and your needs.

Our Location

Allen & Stults Co., Inc.

106 North Main St.
Hightstown, NJ 08520
Main office: 609-448-0110
Toll free: 800-792-8660

Our Providers

Dear Mrs. Mazzoli, Many thanks for all your help over the last few days with Timmy and his first car. We got it yesterday and Timmy is taking off today for New Hampshire. It was a relief knowing that you would have all the answers to my questions and as always, quick to respond to my emails. I attached a photo of Timmy and his car, a product of your knowledge and work...I could never have figured all this out without you!
Tim and Timmy
You have always considered and treated your clients as if they were family. You are an asset to your community. We wish you much continued success and are proud to be your clients and friends.
Thanks "Cappy" for all of the wonderful service and advice you have provided to the fraternity over these many years, Always professional and never too busy to assist in any way
We have had our home and auto through your company for 9 years and have been very happy with the service and prompt responses from our representative - Cathy Mazzolli.
It is no wonder that you have achieved such an honor with the wonderful service and personalized attention you offer your clients.
Through the years, your service to our Society has been greatly appreciated. Our best wishes to you and all who are part of Allen & Stults Co. Inc.
We value our association with you and your staff and wish you many more years of success.